Fierro’s Pizza Montauk is a casual pizza restaurant offering a variety of classic and specialty pizzas along with a selection of salads, heroes, and popular sides. The establishment caters to dine-in, takeout, and delivery customers, making it convenient for quick bites or more relaxed meals. Open daily from late morning through early evening, it serves both lunch and dinner hours with extended closing times on Thursdays and Fridays.
The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, welcoming solo diners, groups, and visitors with children. The restaurant provides wheelchair-accessible parking and on-site parking options, as well as free street parking nearby. Customers can also enjoy the pet-friendly outdoor seating area where dogs are allowed. Payment options include credit and debit cards for added convenience.
Fierro’s Pizza Montauk is known for its approachable comfort food offering, suitable for tourists and locals alike seeking a satisfying and reasonably priced meal. Its location near a popular brewery makes it an ideal stop for a quick, flavorful meal. For a detailed overview of the available dishes, customers are encouraged to explore the full menu to find options that suit various tastes and dietary preferences.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
484 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, United States
290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, United States
170 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, United States
10 S Etna Ave, Montauk, NY 11954, United States
Johann-Fichte-Straße 7, 80805 München, Germany
26 Rue des Jardins, 57000 Metz, France
Poljička Cesta 141, 21315, Dugi Rat, Croatia
2330 Kalākaua Ave # 156, Honolulu, HI 96815, United States
32 Hamilton Rd, Levenshulme, Manchester M13 0PE, United Kingdom
Discover new menus and trending dishes on Menustic.
Menustic helps you discover menus from restaurants, cafés, and bars around the world. Explore destinations, compare dishes and prices, and decide where to eat or drink — Fantastic Menus, One Click Away.
© 2026 Menustic. Built to help people discover menus and decide what to eat and drink.
Ed Simonetti
21/02/2026
My wife and I grabbed a pie this evening to bring back to our campsite. Pizza was fresh. Sauce and crust were delicious. I would highly recommend to anyone to stop in and try it for yourself.
Jillian
31/01/2026
We ordered plain and Sicilian slices and both were delicious. Employees were very helpful and told us they can custom make a pie to accommodate an allergy I have. We will definitely be back!
Gerard M
23/01/2026
Huge variety of excellent pizza. Grab a beer next door at Montauk Brewery, sit on a bench or one of their Adirondack chairs and let your cares melt away. BTW: very friendly staff and the pizza is very fairly priced. I went twice this week
John Kubisa
15/01/2026
Great Slices. Great service. Stop by before or after the brewery .
Moses Burdon
11/01/2026
All the good pizza in East Hampton moved to Montauk when the bougie useless boutiques took over
Sushil Sinha
15/12/2025
Best pizza ever! The Sicilian pizza was fluffy, spongy with the perfect about of crunch to the bread base topped with a delicious slightly sweet tomatoes sauce and perfect amount of cheese. Pepe's Pizza has nothing on these guys.
Stefanie Salita
14/12/2025
It's so great to have another pizza option in Montauk! Especially right near the brewery it's so needed when you just want to grab something quick. My husband I went there just this past weekend and it was delicious on top of the staff being very friendly. The place itself is very clean and smells like fresh food! It will be a new staple for when we go back. You can't go wrong with good Pizza! Thank you for being there :)
Jacques Bertrand
13/12/2025
Nice clean place. Pizza was good, but could’ve been cooked for a little longer which would’ve made it great. Crust was just undercooked. Would definitely come here again.